Technical pens are appealing for pen plotting because they can produce very consistent line widths, but choosing between systems such as the Rotring Isograph and Staedtler Mars Matic is not necessarily as simple as comparing the nominal nib size.
For plotter use, I think some of the more interesting questions are practical ones:
- How reliably does the pen start after being lifted and moved?
- How well does it cope with long plots without the ink flow becoming inconsistent?
- How sensitive is it to being held perfectly vertical?
- How easy is it to clean after a long plotting session?
- Do different nib sizes behave equally well in a plotter, or do the very fine ones become much more demanding?
- Does one system tolerate pauses and repeated pen-up / pen-down movements better than the other?
- How much difference does the ink itself make compared with the pen mechanism?
- And, perhaps most importantly, how much maintenance are you willing to accept in exchange for a very controlled line?
Rotring Isograph and Staedtler Mars Matic are both established technical-pen systems, so I’m less interested in declaring one of them “better” in general than in understanding where their differences actually become noticeable on a drawing machine.
There is also the holder question. A pen that works beautifully by hand may behave differently when it is clamped into a machine, especially if the holder restricts the barrel, introduces a slight angle, or does not allow enough vertical movement.
If you have plotted with either of them — or ideally both — I’d be interested in hearing what you found in real use.
Which one has been more reliable for you, and at what nib sizes?